Archaeologists drill core samples to read the past in layers. Coal Mine Theatre’s new production of David Mamet’s American Buffalo is like one of those samples, drawn from the depths of 1975-era soil: an exquisite act of immersion into a far-away decade, so vividly rendered that it erases the distance from today.
Mamet was 27 when the play premiered at Chicago’s Goodman Theatre in 1975. It tells the story of a single day in Don’s Resale Shop, a Chicago junk store. The store owner Don frets that he sold a buffalo nickel for less than it was worth, and plots with his errand runner Bobby to steal it back … until Don’s poker buddy Teach muscles in. It’s a tortured plot, and it leads to psychological and physical trauma.That first production featured a young William H. Macy as Bobby and won the Obie for Best New American Play.

It’s now 2026, and we’re in Toronto. One room on one day with three men could easily feel static. Coal Mine’s production never does, so deep is the immersion. Ken MacKenzie’s amazing set and props bury us in a shop whose shelves are so crammed — with lampshades, bottles, bins, dishes, statuary and small appliances – that we don’t know quite where to look. In front of them on the left are a table and chairs for eating, drinking and cards. At right is an L-shaped glass display case of valuables, behind which Don presides over his business.
Through back-wall storefront windows dotted with tennis rackets and musical instruments, Steve Lucas’s subtle lighting and Olivia Wheeler’s sound design carry us from dappled daylight to rainy night, cut by the arc of car lights. Nearly every square inch of space seems to hold some object with an unknown but imaginable backstory. It’s endlessly diverting, and it’s no museum piece: when the men come to blows in the second act, David Chinchilla’s fight choreography makes these objects collateral damage. This core sample is living, lived-in … pulsing.
The human immersion is of the same order of magnitude. Under Jordan Laffrenier’s measured direction, and in Des’ree Gray’s well-worn costumes, the three actors bring a compelling and grimy three-dimensionality to this act of time travel. Shawn Doyle’s Don seems firmly in charge at first: fathering the hapless Bobby, pressing cash on him, and entreating him to eat. But there’s a controlling edge to Don’s care, and its flipside is a corrosive suggestibility. Rooted in a creeping sense of injustice and precarity, it leaves Don vulnerable to Teach’s whisperings and conspiracy theories.
Ted Dykstra’s Teach looks, sounds – and schemes – like Macy’s Frank Gallagher from Shameless. (This is fitting, since Macy actually graduated from playing Bobby to playing Teach in a 2000 revival of the play.) Dykstra gives a bravura performance of blustery, seductive overconfidence powered by suspicion and self-interest. Teach gets the funniest lines, which are staggeringly cynical or blindingly Captain Obvious, and Dykstra just nails the delivery. Meanwhile, Mackenzie Wojcik’s Bobby is heart-rendingly earnest, shuffling … and furtive. We’re never sure whether he’s slow, strung out, or simply worn down by the world, which makes him all the more affecting. The three stars play off one another superbly, and never settle into predictability.

Mamet’s legendary dialogue is, of course, a star in its own right. Brilliant in its economy, it carries his themes organically, inside the words of these utterly distinct, real-feeling men. And no theme is more insistently worked than the line between business and friendship.
It comes to life visibly in MacKenzie’s set.The display case and seat are for business.The table, scene of the previous night’s poker game, is for friendship: Bobby and Teach sit down there to eat, drink and shoot the breeze as if they were at home. But as the plot unfolds, the men spend a lot of time and words on the idea of keeping the two apart. “There’s business and there’s friendship, Bobby,” Don counsels at the start. Later, Teach agrees, grandly: “Friendship is friendship, and a wonderful thing … But let’s just keep it separate.” But the distinction feels less like a principle than a tool, reached for to justify or excuse someone’s exclusion or robbery. The crux of the play is the convenience of the distinction … and how quickly it crumbles when real money seems to be on the table. Teach’s memorable definition of free enterprise, the freedom of the individual “to embark on any fucking course that he sees fit,” is where the crumbling leads.
Dig into these rationalizations, and some of it sounds an awful lot like today: the us-versus-them suspicion of MAGA Republicans, and the zero-sum capitalism of a President who smiles as he screws allies like Canada while insisting that it’s “just business” – that every purchase, however essential, is a depletion of America’s bank account that must be tariffed. The Coal Mine itself bills the play as a story of the birth of MAGA, and it’s a depressingly logical case to make.
Here lies the value of this core sample production of American Buffalo. It’s a resonant and rewarding way to disappear into the past, with three characters who aren’t done with you when the lights come up. No – at the close of their chaotic day (which from a business and a friendship standpoint ends quite similarly to the way it started), they make you ask whether they actually learned or accomplished anything … and whether, when we peel back the layers and the years between us, we have collectively learned anything since.
American Buffalo plays at the Coal Mine Theatre, 2076 Danforth Ave., until December 6. For tickets, visit coalminetheatre.com
© Scott Sneddon, Sesaya Arts Magazine 2026
-
Scott Sneddon is Senior Editor on Sesaya Arts Magazine, where he is also a critic and contributor.
Visit About Us > Meet the Team to read Scott's full bio ...

