The revival of a classic musical always begs the question “Why now?” Bowtie Productions’ Pippin, the first major Toronto presentation of the musical in 20 years, answers with a young protagonist who is desperate to be — and, just as importantly, to be perceived as — extraordinary. Pippin is certainly a throwback, but in today’s digital culture of curated feeds chasing the next “like”, he also feels oddly current.
Stephen Schwartz’s 1972 musical, with a book by Roger O. Hirson and Bob Fosse (who also directed the original Broadway production), follows Pippin (Anthony Palermo), who is the son of Charlemagne, the first Carolingian Emperor. On the eve of Pippin’s high-school graduation, he launches his quest for greatness, in which he is guided by the Leading Player (KC Martinez) who also serves as our narrator. As the musical progresses, Pippin tries multiple routes, including war, lust, revolution and performance. But nothing satisfies.

Pippin opens with a young person poised at the threshold of “What now?” The company’s pairing of seasoned artists W. Joseph Matheson and Donna Garner with early-career performers like Palermo and Evans adds a generational charge. And the Leading Player’s constant breaking of the fourth wall to address the house makes the multi-generational audience complicit. We become the measure of engagement that Pippin is performing for. But is he choosing what is meaningful — “extraordinary” as he claims — or only the semblance of it?
Martinez’s Leading Player works the room like a self-assured ringmaster: she narrates the story, cues reactions from the house and the company, and even announces the intermission herself, so the show’s own structure becomes part of the performance. An exquisite singer, she is confident, playful and sufficiently bossy. She keeps promising a “finale,” a climactic payoff that Pippin must reach, in order to count. Meanwhile, Palermo’s bright-eyed and convincingly adrift Pippin is charming enough that we see why eventual love interest Catherine wants him, and vulnerable enough that we worry that his hunger for “more” is a trap.
The Leading Player’s treatment of Catherine is one of the sharpest notes in the work. Krizia Natale gives Catherine warmth, wit, and a quirky groundedness. She is a relentlessly positive, rounded person, rather than a plot device, and her scenes with Palermo are the production’s emotional centre. The Leading Player, though, keeps drawing attention to the fact that Catherine is playing a part. She derides Catherine for going off script and reins her in so she doesn’t interpret her role too personally. In our age of curated selves and algorithmic agendas, it reads as a fight over who controls the narrative. Catherine’s old-fashionedly inconspicuous life feels like resistance … though her son Theo (Max Goodman) seems instead to succumb to the siren call of visibility
The supporting players are strong. Garner plays Pippin’s Grandmother Berthe, and she belts out “No Time at All”, a mischievous, unexpectedly wise singalong, with charisma and charm. Matheson’s Charlemagne delivers his succession of one-liners with a deliciously world-weary shrug. Daniela Bauer plays Pippin’s conniving stepmother Fastrada with a gleeful relish, channeling an impish and determined Olive Oyl. And the rest of the versatile ensemble does great credit to the musical numbers and to Meredith Shedden’s choreography.
Director Olivia Daniels, with associate director Shedden, keeps the staging simple and low-tech: it’s also something of a throwback without elaborate backdrops, screens or projections. Hannah Dulong’s satin and velvet costumes nod to court attire while remaining contemporary: a preference for pants, culottes and short skirts suggests a timeless modernity, rather than some bygone era.

Meredith Wolting’s set uses two stone arches to establish this historical world, while grey benches and blocks are quickly reassembled as seats, beds and steps. It’s an elegant way to ensure nothing competes with the performers. Niall Durcan’s lighting is atmospheric, especially in the battle scenes and in the second act, when the Leading Player halts the production. The musicians, bookending the playing area under music director Jo O’Leary-Ponzo, bring gusto to Schwartz’s score, which does the bulk of the work in making the musical memorable and keeping the show moving.
As noted above, I can squint and see the relevance to the world of 2026. But at the same time, I must acknowledge that Pippin shows its age: in its meandering book and predictable one-liners, and the quaint-feeling climactic celebration of heterosexual marriage …and the long-feeling runtime. But I give full props to Bowtie for their production’s embrace of the show’s many contradictions. Silly yet sincere, and dated yet strangely current, this Pippin is liable to leave us wondering how much of our own lives is truly “extraordinary” … and how much we are simply performing for the world at large.
Pippin runs at Factory Theatre, 125 Bathurst Street, November 15 to 21, 2026. Tickets are available at bowtieproductions.ca.
© Arpita Ghosal, Sesaya Arts Magazine 2026
-
Arpita Ghosal is a Toronto-based arts writer. She founded Sesaya Music in 2004 and Sesaya Arts Magazine in 2012.

